LastPass vs 1Password: Which Password Manager Is More Secure?
No affiliate links or sponsorship. Plan details and US prices come from LastPass and 1Password official pages; security-incident facts come from LastPass’s own blog disclosures. Checked October 27, 2026. We did not perform penetration tests or hands-on vault trials, and there are no screenshots.
Quick answer
For most people choosing on security history and architecture transparency, 1Password is the safer default in 2026; LastPass remains usable if you accept its 2022 incident history, use a strong unique master password, and keep MFA on. 1Password Individual is $3.99/month regularly ($2.99 promo first year, annual billing); Families $5.99 ($4.49 promo). LastPass lists Free, Premium, Families, and business tiers—Premium is commonly quoted at $3/month billed annually on LastPass trial pages; confirm live totals on lastpass.com/pricing.
Key takeaways
- LastPass incidents (official): August 2022 development-environment breach (source code; LastPass said no customer vault access then); later cloud backup incident disclosed through late 2022 into 2023 updates—customer vault backups copied; encrypted fields required master-password-derived keys; URLs in vault backups were not encrypted the same way (LastPass blog, March 1, 2023 update).
- 1Password: documents Secret Key + account password, end-to-end vault encryption, Travel Mode, Watchtower (1Password personal pricing).
- Related: best password managers and password managers for small teams.
Our verdict
Choose 1Password if you want a Secret Key design, family sharing with clear admin controls, and no LastPass-scale backup exfiltration incident in your decision history.
Choose LastPass only if cost or existing vault inertia wins—and you follow LastPass’s own post-incident guidance (strong unique master password, MFA, rotate credentials if your master password was weak or reused).
How we compared
Facts from LastPass blog incident posts, LastPass pricing/feature pages, and 1Password personal pricing/security marketing pages, checked October 27, 2026 (PKT). No independent security audit by BravoTech.
At a glance
| LastPass | 1Password | |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Yes (device-type limits on Free vs Premium) | No free forever personal plan; 14-day trial |
| Personal paid | Premium; Families (6 users); Plus w/ VPN | Individual; Families (invite up to 5) |
| Extra secret | Master password | Account password + Secret Key |
| Notable history | 2022–2023 security incidents (official blog) | Independently audited (per 1Password); no equivalent LastPass-scale 2022 backup disclosure |
LastPass official breach disclosures
We summarize only what LastPass published.
- August 2022: unauthorized access to parts of the LastPass development environment; LastPass stated source code and technical information were taken and that investigation showed no evidence of customer vault access in that incident (LastPass notice).
- Late 2022 backup incident: threat actor used information from the earlier incident to access cloud backup storage; copied customer account metadata and a backup of vault data. LastPass stated sensitive fields (passwords, secure notes, form data) remained encrypted with AES-256 and required a key derived from each user’s master password; website URLs in that backup format were not encrypted the same way.
- March 1, 2023 update: LastPass published further detail on data accessed and recommended actions (LastPass update). Read the primary posts for full scope—do not rely on secondary news alone.
What this means for readers
LastPass argues strong master passwords remain hard to brute-force. If your master password was short, reused, or created under older weaker iteration settings, LastPass recommended reducing risk by changing stored site passwords. We are not asserting that any specific reader’s vault was cracked.
Security models (as documented)
LastPass describes local AES-256 encryption with a master password it does not store, plus MFA options that expand on paid plans (LastPass pricing).
1Password describes end-to-end encryption of vault data and dual protection using an account password and a Secret Key, plus Watchtower alerts and Travel Mode (1Password).
Pricing (US)
| Plan | US price (as published) | Includes |
|---|---|---|
| LastPass Free | $0 | Vault basics; Free vs Premium differences documented on LastPass (device limits, sharing, emergency access) |
| LastPass Premium | About $3/mo billed annually (LastPass trial/upgrade copy; confirm on pricing) | Multi-device, emergency access, priority support features per LastPass |
| LastPass Families | About $4/mo billed annually (Premium + ~$1; confirm on pricing) | Up to 6 Premium-class accounts + shared folders |
| 1Password Individual | $3.99/mo regular; $2.99/mo promo first year (annual) | 1 seat, 1 GB, apps + extensions |
| 1Password Families | $5.99/mo regular; $4.49/mo promo first year (annual) | Invite up to 5 members; shared vaults |
Features
- Both: password generator, autofill, secure notes, MFA for the vault, sharing on paid family/team plans.
- LastPass Free vs Premium differences (devices, sharing, emergency access, hardware MFA) are spelled out in LastPass FAQs on the pricing page.
- 1Password Families adds admin recovery/invite controls and shared vaults; Individual is one seat.
Which should you pick?
- New personal vault in 2026: 1Password Individual or Families unless you have a hard budget constraint.
- Already on LastPass with a strong unique master password + MFA: you can stay, but read the 2022–2023 disclosures and consider whether rotating high-value logins is warranted for your risk tolerance.
- Teams: compare LastPass Business vs 1Password Business on each vendor’s business pricing pages (not fully priced in this consumer-focused refresh).
FAQ
Was LastPass breached?
Yes. LastPass publicly disclosed a 2022 development-environment incident and a related cloud backup incident in which customer vault backups were copied. Read LastPass’s blog posts linked in Sources for the company’s exact wording.
Were LastPass master passwords stolen in plaintext?
LastPass states it does not know master passwords and that encrypted vault fields require a key derived from the master password. Metadata and unencrypted URL fields in the stolen backup format are a separate issue described in the disclosure.
Is 1Password free?
No personal free forever plan; 1Password offers a 14-day trial of Individual/Families.
Which is cheaper?
LastPass Premium is typically less expensive than 1Password Individual at list promo/regular rates, but price should not be the only factor after LastPass’s incidents. Confirm live prices before buying.
Sources
LastPass and 1Password official pages, checked October 27, 2026.
Changelog
- October 27, 2026: Refresh: added factual summary of LastPass official 2022–2023 breach disclosures with primary links; updated 1Password Individual/Families US prices including promo vs regular; softened LastPass dollar figures where the pricing page hides amounts; removed unsourced “most secure” absolutes; linked password-manager roundups; no hands-on testing.
Related reads
How this article was made. We drafted this article with the help of AI tools, working from the official pages listed in Sources. Prices, plan limits and steps were checked against those pages on October 27, 2026. We did not test these products hands-on for this article. Spot an error? Email [email protected].




